Michael Carrick took training at Carrington on Tuesday morning, and by lunchtime the question that had hung over Manchester United since Sunday had a temporary answer. He will be in the dugout at Stamford Bridge on Saturday. Whether this amounts to a reprieve or simply a delay is the part nobody at the club has cleared up.
BBC Sport, Sky Sports and The Guardian all reported that United have decided to give the 45-year-old the chance to turn things around, at least for the trip to Chelsea. The call surprised plenty of people. After the 3-0 home defeat by Bournemouth, United sit 16th, one point and two places above the relegation zone, and have gone eight games without a win in all competitions.
How United got here
The collapse has been quick. Carrick took interim charge in January after Ruben Amorim's sacking, and according to Sky Sports he won 12 of his 17 matches to drag the club to third place and back into the Champions League. That run earned him the permanent job in May.
This season has been the opposite. United have won one of their eight Premier League matches, per BBC Sport, and The Guardian counts just two wins in 12 games across all competitions, with a Carabao Cup exit to Brighton among them. The Champions League has offered no relief: a 2-0 defeat by Atlético Madrid, then a 4-1 thrashing at Como.
The dressing room has started to talk. After the Atlético loss, Lisandro Martínez criticised the board for a lack of investment. After Como, captain Bruno Fernandes questioned Carrick's tactics. Carrick dropped him to the bench for Bournemouth, and he stayed there for 90 minutes.
A reprieve, not a vote of confidence
On Monday, director of football Jason Wilcox and chief executive Omar Berrada were at the training ground discussing Carrick's future, Sky Sports reported. According to The Guardian, it was Wilcox who pushed to keep him, wanting to give the coach a chance to transform form and results.
The paper also floated a less flattering reading: the extra time might let Wilcox line up a replacement should the club decide to make a change. Nothing United have said publicly has knocked that theory down. BBC Sport noted there was no clarification on Monday, before or after Carrick watched an Under-21 game that his son Jacey played in, nor on Tuesday after his 07:30 arrival at Carrington.
Sky Sports News reporter Rob Dorsett did not see much comfort in it. "This isn't a vote of confidence. It doesn't feel like Man Utd are saying, 'He's our man, we're sticking with him'," he said. Gary Neville admitted he was surprised. "I was absolutely certain that what I witnessed on Sunday would be the end of Michael," the former United captain told Sky Sports.
The supporters, at least, have chosen a side. At full time on Sunday, the Stretford End sang Carrick's name and then booed the players. "Mixed emotions for the supporters to respond in that way," Carrick said afterwards, as quoted by BBC Sport. "We haven't had results or performances that have been good enough."
The names in the frame
The shortlist is already public. BBC Sport and Sky Sports both name Eddie Howe and Julian Nagelsmann. The Guardian reports that Howe, out of work since leaving Newcastle in July, is Wilcox's preferred choice, and that United would owe Newcastle about £3m in compensation, plus a smaller sum for his staff led by assistant Jason Tindall.
Nagelsmann, 39, resigned as Germany head coach after their World Cup quarter-final exit and is aware of United's interest, according to BBC Sport. The Guardian adds that recruitment director Christopher Vivell has been pushing his case. BBC Sport also reports that Aston Villa's Unai Emery is admired, although his contract makes any approach complicated.
Three games before the break
Chelsea are not an easy place to start a recovery for the 13-time Premier League champions. Xabi Alonso's side are fifth and six points better off than United after eight games, Sky Sports reported, even after losing 2-0 at home to Tottenham. Last season's win at Stamford Bridge was one of the results that won Carrick the job, a point BBC Sport made.
After Saturday, United host Roma in the Champions League on Tuesday 3 November and Aston Villa in the league on Sunday 8 November, before a two-week international break. Those 14 days are the natural moment for a change if the club wants one.
The first decision is about Fernandes. Bring the captain back and Carrick risks looking weak; leave him out again and the stand-off becomes the story. Either way, the next 90 minutes in west London on Saturday lunchtime may decide more than three points.
Sources
- BBC Sport: Michael Carrick to stay in charge of Man Utd for Chelsea game
- Sky Sports: Man Utd boss Michael Carrick to remain in charge vs Chelsea
- The Guardian: Carrick given chance to save job as he stays for Manchester United's game at Chelsea
- Sky Sports: Eddie Howe and Julian Nagelsmann expected frontrunners if Carrick departs
No comments yet