The Memorial Stand at Highbury Stadium, home of Fleetwood Town, during a League Two match. Photo: Steve Daniels via Wikimedia Commons (geograph.org.uk), CC BY-SA 2.0

Fleetwood stun Arsenal: how a League Two side knocked out the champions on penalties

Fleetwood Town reached the Carabao Cup quarter-finals for the first time after a 1-1 draw and a perfect 5-3 shootout against Arsenal, with Jay Lynch the hero and Max Dowman sent off.

On this page

Fleetwood Town are in the quarter-finals of the Carabao Cup for the first time in their history, and the Premier League champions are out. The League Two side drew 1-1 with Arsenal at Highbury Stadium on Tuesday night, then scored all 5 of their penalties to win the shootout 5-3, with 19-year-old centre-back Conor Haughey sending the last one into the top corner.

BBC Sport called it one of the biggest upsets in the competition's history. The gap on paper was enormous: Fleetwood sit 84 places below Arsenal in the English pyramid, according to the BBC, and Sky Sports noted they are only 2 points above the League Two relegation zone. As recently as 2012 they were a non-league club.

A drone, a debut and a goal against the run of play

The night started strangely. Play was stopped after 93 seconds because an unidentified drone was hovering over the ground, and the restart came after a delay of around 7 minutes, per Sky Sports and Arsenal's own match report.

Mikel Arteta had picked a strong side, with Viktor Gyökeres and Kai Havertz up front, but he also handed Illan Meslier his Arsenal debut in goal, choosing him over Kepa Arrizabalaga.

Meslier was beaten after 21 minutes. Harrison Neal slipped a pass through midfield, Aaron Loupalo-Bi muscled past 17-year-old defender Marli Salmon and finished low between the goalkeeper's legs. A crowd of 5,002, according to the BBC, could hardly believe it.

Arsenal took until the 29th minute to put a shot on target, and even 7 minutes of first-half stoppage time produced only a Jurriën Timber header over the bar. Their response came early in the second half, after Arteta sent on Martin Ødegaard and Ben White. Ceadach O'Neill, making his first start, delivered the ball that caused chaos in the box, and Gyökeres flicked in his first goal of the season on 50 minutes.

Arsenal's chances, Lynch's hands

From there it should have been routine. It was not. Havertz missed 3 or 4 of the best openings, by Sky Sports' count, heading wide, firing over and hitting the side netting. Myles Lewis-Skelly curled one wide and then missed from close range. Sky Sports counted 19 Arsenal shots off target across the night.

Fleetwood goalkeeper Jay Lynch became the story. He tipped a Havertz effort over the bar and, during 5 added minutes at the end, kept out White on the line and then Ødegaard, both from close range. Those two stops took the tie to penalties.

Before that came the moment that will follow Arsenal into the weekend. With about 5 minutes of normal time left, Max Dowman reacted to a heavy challenge from Neal by kicking out, and referee Michael Salisbury showed the 16-year-old a straight red card. Sky co-commentator Andy Hinchcliffe called it "really harsh". As Dowman walked past the dugout, Arteta leaned in and said something to him.

The shootout and the reaction

Both teams scored their first 3 kicks. Ronan Coughlan, Neal and Will Davies converted for Fleetwood, while Ødegaard, Havertz and Gyökeres replied. Andy Cannon put the hosts 4-3 up, Lynch dived to his left to save from Bruno Guimarães, and Haughey finished it.

Fleetwood head coach Matt Lawlor admitted the precision was not rehearsed. "I'm going to be honest, we haven't practised once," he said, as quoted by Sky Sports. "We have a 19-year-old centre-back that took the last one. I was a little bit worried when he was walking up, but Conor backs himself."

Arteta did not blame effort. "I cannot fault at all the attitude of the players," he told BBC Sport. "We have so much of the ball, so many chances, so many shots, and if you want the margins to be bigger than going to the penalties, obviously, you need to capitalise on that. And we didn't."

Asked what he said to Dowman, Arteta would only reply, "It was something that we discussed before the game," Sky Sports reported. He added that the squad had been told what to expect: "The things that emotionally we have to dominate and it was very clear." On the red card itself he said he had not seen a clear replay.

That exchange drew criticism. Paul Merson said on Sky Sports that Arteta would not have done the same to "an experienced international" like Gyökeres. "If it was me, I'd have put my arm around him," Merson said.

What it costs Arsenal

The exit removes 1 of 4 trophies from Arsenal's season, and it arrives at an awkward moment. Arteta told Football London that Riccardo Calafiori and Noni Madueke (ankle) were unavailable and that Declan Rice had been carrying a problem from the previous game.

Sky Sports reported that Arsenal hope to have a ruling on Dowman's red card before they travel to Liverpool. A straight red for violent conduct normally carries a 3-match ban in England, so the outcome matters for a teenager who has become one of Arteta's main sources of creativity.

What comes next

Arsenal have no time to dwell on it. They face Liverpool at Anfield on Sunday 1 November at 16:30 UK time, then go to Slavia Prague in the Champions League, their third away game in a row.

Fleetwood, meanwhile, go back to the league on Saturday. "I didn't want to be the bearer of reality, but we've got a game," Lawlor said. They will be in the quarter-final draw alongside the winners of the remaining ties, including Bradford, who beat Peterborough on the same night, according to BBC Sport. Whoever draws them now knows exactly what Highbury Stadium can do.

Sources

No comments yet