Manchester United and Bournemouth players line up for a set piece at Old Trafford in a Premier League match in March 2017. Photo: Ardfern, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Man Utd 0-3 Bournemouth: Carrick benches Fernandes and is left on the brink

Michael Carrick dropped his captain, Bournemouth won 3-0 at Old Trafford through Rayan, Tavernier and Evanilson, and United are 16th, eight games without a win and one point above the drop zone.

On this page

Michael Carrick made the biggest call of his time in charge on Sunday, leaving his captain on the bench, and Bournemouth answered it for him. Goals from Rayan, Marcus Tavernier and Evanilson gave Marco Rose's side a 3-0 win at Old Trafford, and by the final whistle the question was no longer whether Bruno Fernandes should play, but whether Carrick will still be in the job by the end of the week.

United are now 8 games without a win in all competitions and sit 16th in the Premier League on 7 points, 1 point above the relegation zone and 14 behind the leaders. Carrick, asked by reporters whether he expected to be sacked, said: "I am not expecting anything."

The Fernandes gamble

The selection came out of a chaotic week. After Wednesday's 4-1 Champions League defeat at Como, Fernandes publicly questioned his manager's tactics, a few days after Lisandro Martínez had issued an apology for criticising the club's hierarchy following the 2-0 loss at Atlético Madrid, as BBC Sport reported. Carrick called the captain's omission "a football decision" before kick-off. Harry Maguire wore the armband, with Mason Mount and Youri Tielemans asked to run the midfield.

It was, according to BBC Sport, only the 6th time Fernandes had started a Premier League game on the bench. He never came off it. Carrick sent on Matheus Cunha for the poor Tielemans at half-time, then Martínez, Joshua Zirkzee and Shea Lacey, and the Manchester Evening News reported that Fernandes had been told to warm up in the second half before being left as an unused substitute.

Jamie Carragher, on Sky Sports, thought that was deliberate. "I don't think he was ever going to bring him on," he said. Carrick would only tell Sky Sports: "There's always times when you're trying to make decisions that are to change the course of play and made a difference but those are the decisions we made today."

How Bournemouth took it apart

The visitors were the better side long before they scored. Ayden Heaven's wild lunge conceded a free-kick, Justin Kluivert delivered it, and Rayan volleyed in at the far post on 38 minutes. Carrick later called the free-kick "dubious". Shortly before the break Leny Yoro slipped and Tavernier slotted in the second, which brought boos from the home crowd and chants of "sacked in the morning" from the away end, Sky Sports reported.

The third came on 71 minutes. Adams swung a pass in behind, Evanilson beat the onrushing Senne Lammens to it and, from outside the box with Maguire scrambling back, swung a stunning finish high into the far side-netting, as The Guardian described it. It was a 4th straight win in all competitions for Rose's side, after Thursday's 3-0 Europa League win over Milan, and it lifts them to 14th on 9 points.

"We wanted to be front-footed. We wanted to be brave and we played brave," Rose told his press conference. "We were just Bournemouth today." He also offered something rarely heard from a winning manager at this ground: "I feel empathy for Michael."

The numbers behind the pressure

BBC Sport's figures make grim reading. United have 7 points from 8 league games (W1 D4 L3), their lowest total at this stage of a top-flight season since 1986-87, when they had 4. This is their first eight-game winless run in all competitions since November and December 2015, and their heaviest home league defeat since another 3-0 loss to Bournemouth in December 2024. They have not won a league game since 30 August.

Bournemouth's own record here is just as telling. This was their third win by 3 or more goals at Old Trafford, and since 1992-93 only Liverpool, with 4, have done it more often. Since the start of 2023-24, no Premier League side has lost more home games by 3 or more goals in all competitions than United, with 7.

Carrick, 45, took interim charge in January after Ruben Amorim's departure, guided United to third and the Champions League, and was given the job permanently in May. He has won only 2 Premier League matches since.

The supporters drew a clear line. They sang Carrick's name as he walked down the tunnel, then booed the players, and directed their anger at the Glazer family, Sir Jim Ratcliffe and technical director Jason Wilcox, according to Sky Sports.

What happens now

Gary Neville did not hide his reading of it. "Michael Carrick is popular. But the owners, the sporting department and the players are not popular. They have badly let the club down," he said on Sky Sports. "Tomorrow, they will probably make a decision that will disgust Manchester United fans but it is probably necessary. The club is a mess."

Maguire insisted the dressing room had not turned. "We're fully behind Michael," he told BBC Sport. "As individuals, we're not playing well enough."

Carrick himself denied that the scenes at the end had been a goodbye. "It wasn't a farewell from me," he told Sky Sports. "It's a tough situation, there's no hiding from it. What it looks like and what's next I really don't know. I will always do my best for the football club and I won't change that now."

The Independent reported that Eddie Howe is the bookmakers' favourite if United make a change, and that under-18s coach Darren Fletcher could be an interim option. None of that is confirmed. What is certain is that United's next league fixture is away at Chelsea on Saturday, and that whoever picks the team will have to decide what to do about the captain.

Sources

No comments yet