Two rebuilds, two moods
Newcastle United and Aston Villa meet at St James' Park on Saturday (17:30 BST) carrying very different midweek memories. Newcastle were beaten 4-1 at newly promoted Coventry City on Monday. Villa thrashed Fenerbahçe 6-0 at Villa Park on Wednesday, their biggest win in major European competition, according to Sky Sports.
The Premier League table tells a less flattering story for the visitors. Villa sit 16th with 5 points from 6 games, 1 win, 2 draws and 3 defeats, with 6 goals scored and 11 conceded, BBC Sport's standings show. Newcastle are 11th on 8 points after 2 wins, 2 draws and 2 defeats, but their goal difference of minus 3 reflects a defence that has shipped 13.
Matthias Jaissle replaced Eddie Howe in August, arriving from Saudi club Al Ahli after two Asian Champions League titles, as Sky Sports and AP reported at the time. Villa sold Ollie Watkins in the summer and, per Sky Sports, have leaned on Nicolas Jackson, who worked with Emery at Villarreal and now has 3 Champions League goals in 2 games.
Jaissle: a young squad must learn fast
Jaissle refused to hide behind shape or system after Coventry. "We made too many individual mistakes so these things we need to avoid otherwise you get punished in this league," he told Newcastle's official website. "Even though we're a young squad, we need to learn fast."
He also told BBC Sport that "you cannot talk about formation or technical approach" after a night like that.
The injury list is still long. Bazoumana Touré came off late at Coventry, but Jaissle said: "Bazou seems to be much better. We're happy for that (as) it didn't look well during the match." Joelinton and Dan Burn made their first appearances of 2026-27 on Monday. Joelinton could start, while for Burn "it will most likely be too soon to get that starting position already", Jaissle said.
Anthony Elanga, Tino Livramento and former Villa midfielder Jacob Ramsey remain out. The Guardian's team news lists all three with a 25 October target and Jaouen out until December with a hamstring problem.
Jaissle was blunt about the opposition. "It gives them a huge boost," he said of Villa's 6-0 night. "We are aware what we are facing but at home, with our crowd backing us, we can hurt every opponent."
Emery wants 100%, not 80%
Emery delayed his team selection until after Friday's training. "Some players may be tired, some can feel some pain, not injuries but maybe pain," he said, in comments carried by BBC Sport and The Mag. He wants starters who are "not 80%, to be 100%".
"Newcastle at home is always very difficult. They are going to press, they're going to play with their supporters pushing them," Emery said. "We will need players on the bench ready to play in case we need fresh legs."
On Newcastle's summer changes, Emery said: "Some players who left, especially in the middle, Bruno Guimarães and Sandro Tonali, they can feel some differences in players and performances," adding that Nico González can "replace them with the quality he has".
Emery listed the recent evidence of progress: a home defeat by Nottingham Forest, then a win at Tottenham and a draw with Brentford in the league. "We are building the team in the same way we did it three, two, and one years ago," he said.
Sky Sports noted that after scoring once in their first 4 games of the season, Villa have scored 3 or more in 4 of their last 6 in all competitions, and Jackson has scored in each of his last 2 league appearances.
Villa have their own absentees. The Guardian lists Ian Maatsen (ankle), Ruggeri (hamstring) and Amadou Onana (knee ligament) as injured, with three more players doubtful. Jarred Gillett referees, per the same preview.
History offers Newcastle comfort and a warning. The hosts are chasing a fifth win in their last 6 Premier League home games against Villa, according to Newcastle's club site. Yet Villa won 2-0 on their last visit in January, through Emiliano Buendía and Watkins, their first win at St James' Park since April 2005 and the end of a 17-game winless run there, the Premier League's match report noted.
A win would take Newcastle to 11 points and quieten the Coventry noise. Defeat would leave Villa's league form trailing badly behind the European glow, with a 5-point haul from 7 games.
Key facts
- Fixture: Newcastle United vs Aston Villa, St James' Park, Saturday 17 October 2026, 17:30 BST.
- Newcastle: 11th, 8 points from 6 games (W2 D2 L2), 10 scored, 13 conceded.
- Aston Villa: 16th, 5 points from 6 games (W1 D2 L3), 6 scored, 11 conceded.
- Monday: Coventry City 4-1 Newcastle United.
- Wednesday: Aston Villa 6-0 Fenerbahçe (Jackson 2, Barkley 2, Manzambi, Abraham); 2 wins from 2 in the Champions League.
- Newcastle out: Elanga, Livramento, Ramsey, Jaouen; Touré expected to recover from a knock.
- Joelinton could start; Burn "most likely too soon" for a starting place.
- Villa out: Maatsen, Ruggeri, Onana (The Guardian).
- Villa won 2-0 at St James' Park on 25 January 2026, their first win there since April 2005.
Sources
- BBC Sport: Matthias Jaissle press conference, Newcastle vs Aston Villa
- BBC Sport: Unai Emery press conference, Newcastle vs Aston Villa
- Newcastle United: Jaissle's team news update before Villa
- Sky Sports: Aston Villa 6-0 Fenerbahce report
- The Guardian: Saturday matchday live, Newcastle v Aston Villa preview and team news
- The Mag: Unai Emery on Aston Villa and Newcastle's summer changes
- AP News: Newcastle hires Matthias Jaissle to replace Eddie Howe
- BBC Sport: Premier League table
- Premier League: Newcastle 0-2 Aston Villa match report, January 2026
- Sky Sports: Newcastle appoint Matthias Jaissle
No comments yet