Aerial view of Old Trafford, home of Manchester United. Photo: Arne Müseler, CC BY-SA 3.0 de, via Wikimedia Commons

Man Utd vs Roma: Carrick defiant as nine games without a win turn Old Trafford into a week of reckoning

Nine without a win, 17th in the league and 21st in Europe: Michael Carrick insists his dressing room is intact as an unbeaten Roma visit Old Trafford with his future on the line.

On this page

Michael Carrick walked into his pre-Roma press conference on Monday with Manchester United nine games without a win, 17th in the Premier League and 21st in the Champions League league phase. He walked out still sounding like a man who plans to be around long after Tuesday night.

"It's what I am and what I live for," Carrick said when asked how he stays positive through a run this bad. "A lot of people could do my job when you're winning a lot of football games. It's about finding solutions."

Roma arrive at Old Trafford (20:00 GMT, Tuesday 3 November) unbeaten in Serie A, one point and six places above United in the 36-team table. For Carrick, this is the first of two games that will very likely decide whether he survives the November international break.

How bad is it, really

The numbers are brutal. United have not won since mid-September, a nine-game run across all competitions with three draws and six defeats, according to Opta Analyst. BBC Sport called it the club's longest winless spell since October and November 1988, while Opta data quoted by Reuters takes it back even further, to 1984.

In the league, United have seven points from nine games and sit above Crystal Palace and the relegation zone only on goal difference. They have failed to score in four of those nine matches. Saturday's 2-0 loss at Stamford Bridge, where Lisandro Martínez was sent off for a second booking, came after a 3-0 home defeat by Bournemouth and a 4-1 thrashing at Como in Europe.

Opta also notes that United have lost seven of their last 10 Champions League games, their worst run ever in the competition.

Erik ten Hag, sacked by United in 2024, added fuel on Sunday. Asked by ESPN about relegation, he said: "In the Premier League it's certainly possible, because all the teams are simply strong."

The two-game window

The Guardian reported on Sunday that Carrick came close to losing his job last Monday, when director of football Jason Wilcox and chief executive Omar Berrada met at the training ground to discuss his future. They decided to give him a chance, and his position is expected to be reviewed again during the international break, after Sunday's home game against Aston Villa.

According to the same report, Eddie Howe is Wilcox's preferred candidate if Carrick goes, and Julian Nagelsmann is highly regarded by recruitment director Christopher Vivell.

Carrick refused to frame it as a countdown. "You never know what's going to happen but that doesn't affect how we prepare for the game tomorrow," he told reporters. "Whatever happens after that, happens after that."

Much of the questioning was about whether the squad is still with him, and Carrick pushed back hard. "The dressing room is a good place. Perception is a funny thing," he said. "The commitment of the players, to the club, to me, to each other, do not question at all."

He also defended Martínez after the red card at Chelsea: "I have no concerns about his commitment. Things happen in football. Sometimes you make mistakes." On the contracts of Martínez and Bruno Fernandes, both due to expire in summer 2027, he offered only: "Nothing to update at the moment."

Luke Shaw will miss the game, Marcus Rashford will be assessed "day by day", and Patrick Dorgu is back in training but not ready for Roma. Benjamin Šeško remains United's main absentee.

Kobbie Mainoo, sitting next to his manager, struck the same note. He said the team is "one win away" from turning things around and thanked Carrick for "putting the trust in me".

Roma, the in-form visitor with a weak spot

Gian Piero Gasperini's side are the opposite story. Roma are unbeaten in 17 Serie A games stretching back to last season, have scored 21 goals in their last six matches and thumped Udinese 5-2 on Saturday. In Europe they lost 4-3 to Real Madrid after conceding three times in the final eight minutes, then beat Slovan Bratislava for their first Champions League win since 2019.

Gasperini warned his players not to read too much into United's slump. "They are going through a difficult moment in terms of results, but we can't let ourselves be distracted," he said, according to Corriere dello Sport. "We are preparing as if we were facing the best Manchester United." Lorenzo Pellegrini, Paulo Dybala and Manu Koné are all missing.

History, though, leans United's way. Roma have not won on any of their last 16 trips to England, have won just two of their last 20 Champions League away games, and have conceded in 32 straight Champions League away matches. United have won all four previous meetings at Old Trafford, and Carrick scored twice in the famous 7-1 quarter-final win over Roma in 2007.

What's next

The Opta supercomputer still makes United slight favourites, with a 40.9% win probability against 34.8% for Roma and 24.3% for a draw. A win would lift United to six points with four games left, still well short of what they likely need for the top 24 but alive.

Then comes Villa on Sunday. Carrick insisted, "We are still in it." By the time the international break starts, United's hierarchy will have decided whether they believe him.

Key facts

  • Match: Manchester United vs Roma, Champions League league phase matchday 4, Tuesday 3 November 2026, 20:00 GMT, Old Trafford.
  • United form: nine games without a win in all competitions (three draws, six defeats).
  • Premier League: United 17th with seven points from nine games, above the drop zone on goal difference.
  • Champions League: United 21st with three points, Roma 15th with four.
  • United have lost seven of their last 10 Champions League games, their worst run in the competition, per Opta.
  • Carrick's future is expected to be reviewed during the international break, after Aston Villa at home on Sunday, per the Guardian.
  • Out for United: Luke Shaw, Patrick Dorgu, Benjamin Šeško; Marcus Rashford is a doubt.
  • Out for Roma: Pellegrini, Dybala and Koné; Gasperini says midfield numbers are tight.
  • Roma: unbeaten in 17 Serie A games, 21 goals in their last six matches.
  • Roma have not won in their last 16 visits to England and have conceded in 32 straight Champions League away games.
  • Head to head: United have won all four previous meetings at Old Trafford.
  • Opta prediction: United 40.9%, draw 24.3%, Roma 34.8%.

Sources

No comments yet