Clubs react to Burnham's City remarks
Some Premier League clubs were so "astonished" by Andy Burnham's comments on Manchester City that they are now "concerned" about political interference in the club's appeal, senior sources told BBC Sport on Thursday 8 October.
The prime minister had told the BBC he would be "really concerned" if City's owners decided to sell after an independent commission found the club guilty of Premier League financial-rule breaches. Club figures questioned what the remarks were designed to achieve and said they put the Independent Football Regulator in a difficult position, BBC Sport reports.
One senior source called the comments "absolutely bizarre" and "at best naive and at worst quite manipulative, and that looks bad." Another labelled them "clumsy." A further source said they were surprised the prime minister had "misspoken."
Burnham pushed back on Thursday. "No I haven't downplayed the seriousness of the findings. They are findings that need to be considered with great care and seriousness and then the process that considers them needs to be fully independent," he said, according to BBC Sport. "I think it's incumbent on everybody now to let the process run its course."
How the independent process is meant to work
The charges process sits outside the Premier League's day-to-day control. An independent commission held a 42-day hearing in 2024 before last month's verdict. A sanctions hearing is still to come. A separate independent appeal board will hear City's appeal. The club continues to deny wrongdoing and, GB News notes, lodged its appeal on 1 October.
When asked about interference fears, one senior club source told the BBC: "Everyone would have a degree of concern. How much would depend on how much you read into that comment. I think everyone is concerned. Because no-one is stupid around the table."
"We understand the geopolitics as well. We understand the investment they have made in our country. But this is different, this is sport, this is our national game," the same source added.
Another source took the opposite view: the scrutiny now on Burnham makes any interference impossible. Conservative leader Kemi Badenoch has demanded that No 10 release details of meetings between the prime minister and senior City figures.
From Everton parallel to No 10's "if" edit
Burnham's original interview with political editor Chris Mason also drew an Everton parallel. He said he still held "firmly" that Everton "weren't fairly treated" after a 10-point deduction, later cut to six on appeal, for financial-rule breaches. Asked about losing City's owners, he said: "I would be really concerned to lose them. They've been such a huge partner in the building of modern Manchester."
He spent nine years as Greater Manchester mayor from 2017 until earlier this year and championed Gulf investment in the region's economy. When verdicts landed, Premier League chief executive Richard Masters said City had "systematically broke Premier League rules for nearly a decade," BBC Sport recalls.
A No 10 spokesperson later clarified that the judgement is serious, nobody is above the rules, and the independent process must run its course. The statement first said those responsible should face consequences "if" wrongdoing is established, then amended "if" to "wherever" after further criticism, the BBC reports. Burnham on Thursday stressed separating football issues from wider UK-UAE investment ties.
Key facts
- Burnham comment date: BBC interview after City guilty verdict.
- Club reaction reported: Thursday 8 October 2026 (BBC Sport).
- Independent hearing: 42 days in 2024.
- City appeal lodged: 1 October (GB News).
- Everton precedent: 10 points cut to 6 on appeal.
- Masters line: systematic breaches for nearly a decade.
- No 10 edit: "if" changed to "wherever" on consequences wording.
- Burnham as mayor: 2017 to 2026 (nine years).
- Badenoch demand: release meeting records with City figures.
- Process: separate appeal board; sanctions hearing still pending.

No comments yet