The Etihad Stadium seen from Rylance Street in east Manchester on a rainy afternoon, July 2023 (Ridiculopathy, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons)

Man City held settlement talks with the Premier League before the guilty verdict, Bloomberg reports

The early-stage talks would have centred on a large payment rather than relegation or lost titles. They collapsed quickly, and City now head to Anfield with an appeal pending and sanctions still unknown.

On this page

Talks that never got far

Manchester City sat down with the Premier League to explore a settlement before the independent commission found them guilty, according to a Bloomberg report published on Friday and carried by The Straits Times. People with knowledge of the matter told Bloomberg the talks were early-stage and fell apart quickly, with City holding firm to their innocence.

The shape of the deal is the striking part. Any settlement would have centred on a sizeable financial payment, not relegation and not the stripping of titles, the same people said. Even then, it would only have shrunk the case rather than closed it, because of the sheer number of charges.

Representatives for City and the league both declined to comment, Bloomberg reported. Nothing here amounts to an admission. A settlement of that kind would not have required City to accept wrongdoing, The Mirror noted.

What the commission found

The context is a verdict that landed over the international break. The commission found City guilty of all but one of the charges, 114 in total, covering nine seasons between 2009-10 and 2017-18.

According to The Mirror, the panel ruled that City "clearly intended to circumvent Premier League rules" through a "disguised funding scheme". Revenue was inflated by more than £830m, image rights income was exaggerated by almost £74m and staff liabilities were understated by almost £17m. Richard Masters called it "the most significant in Premier League history".

City lodged their appeal at 7pm on Thursday 1 October. The club says the ruling "contains clear material errors, of law, principle and fact and is unsafe". Bloomberg says a verdict from the new three-person appeal board is due by early February.

Sky Sports puts it sooner. Under this season's fast-track rules, chief correspondent Kaveh Solhekol says, the appeal must finish within 12 weeks, the hearing can last only 5 days and the panel then has 30 days to rule. That points to the third week of January, unless City argue the new rules should not apply to a case that began years ago.

City have settled before

A deal with a regulator would not be new for this club. In 2014, Sky Sports recalls, City agreed a settlement with UEFA that included a £49m fine, £32m of it suspended. UEFA is now monitoring the Premier League case and will wait for it to end before deciding on any action of its own.

Any deal would likely have met fierce resistance. Arsenal, Liverpool and Manchester United all missed out on titles during City's run, and the Mirror report says they would have opposed it strongly.

The noise has not stopped. On The Overlap, Gary Neville said "the owners should go", that titles should be stripped and that there should be "a multi-year points punishment", the Manchester Evening News reported. The case has also reached Westminster, where Prime Minister Andy Burnham's comments thanking City's owners have angered politicians in his own party.

Football carries on

On the pitch, City are top of the table and travel to Anfield on Sunday. Enzo Maresca told reporters: "We trust completely the club. We understand the noise but the focus for us is just what we can control."

Mikel Arteta was more guarded before Arsenal hosted Leeds. "My position and the club's position is not to make any further comment until it is resolved," he told BBC Sport. Andoni Iraola, preparing Liverpool for City, wants a quick ending. "This uncertainty is no good for anyone," he said.

Key facts

  • Report: Bloomberg, published 9 October 2026.
  • Talks: early-stage, before the verdict, and they broke down quickly.
  • Proposed basis: a large financial payment, not relegation or lost titles.
  • Verdict: guilty on 114 charges, all but one.
  • Period: nine seasons, 2009-10 to 2017-18.
  • Revenue inflation: more than £830m, per the commission.
  • Image rights: almost £74m exaggerated.
  • Appeal lodged: 7pm on 1 October 2026.
  • Appeal verdict: early February per Bloomberg, third week of January per Sky Sports.
  • Next match: Liverpool v City at Anfield on Sunday.

Sources

No comments yet