Old Trafford during Manchester United v Aston Villa in September 2021. Photo: Ardfern, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Man Utd 4-4 Aston Villa: Zirkzee and Dorgu rescue Carrick's side from 4-2 down in stoppage time

Villa led twice by two goals at Old Trafford, the last time deep into stoppage time. Zirkzee and a Dorgu header salvaged a point, but United still go into the break in the bottom three.

On this page

Five days after coming from two goals down to beat Roma, Manchester United went 2-0 down inside four minutes at Old Trafford again. Then they came back from two down twice in one afternoon, the second time from 4-2 behind in stoppage time. Joshua Zirkzee pulled one back in the 92nd minute and Patrick Dorgu headed in the equaliser with almost the last touch, after Zion Suzuki missed a corner, to make it 4-4 against Aston Villa.

The point, confirmed after a VAR check, kept the madness alive. It did not change the bigger picture. United go into the international break 18th, on eight points from 10 games, and their only Premier League win this season came on 30 August, 5-2 at home to Ipswich, per Goal.

Two down in four minutes, again

Alysson scored in the first minute, from a John McGinn assist, and Nicolas Jackson made it 2-0 on four minutes. The Independent called it the earliest United have been two down in a Premier League game.

What followed was United's best half-hour in weeks. Boubacar Kamara fouled Matheus Cunha in the box and Bruno Fernandes converted the penalty on 16 minutes. Suzuki's goal was peppered after that, as Sky Sports put it, and on 44 minutes Youri Tielemans, against his old club, levelled from Noussair Mazraoui's pass.

Undone, then undone again

It took Villa three minutes of the second half to lead again. Diogo Dalot lunged at Alysson, referee Chris Kavanagh pointed to the spot and McGinn drove in the penalty on 48 minutes. Five minutes later Leny Yoro almost headed into his own net, the ball bounced around the six-yard box and Leon Goretzka, set up by Jackson, finished calmly.

"And once again, United have conceded two at the start of a half," The Guardian's live coverage noted. Many supporters had left by the time it turned again, Sky Sports noted. BBC Radio 5 Live's Andy Reid was blunt afterwards: "I don't think some of these players are of the standard of Man United players of previous. They're a mid-table team at the moment."

Carrick sent on Mason Mount and Shea Lacey on 66 minutes, with Dorgu also off the bench, and Zirkzee on 83. Then the substitutes took over. Dorgu set up Zirkzee to sweep in, Lacey's delivery in the final minute earned a corner, and Dorgu was there when Suzuki failed to claim it. BBC Sport and The Independent both reported that Unai Emery stormed off at the final whistle.

"That's incredible," Reid said. "The goal has been given, what an incredible game of football."

BBC Sport's numbers backed the idea that United deserved something: 26 shots to Villa's 12, nine on target to six, and 56 per cent of the ball. Expected goals finished 3.55 to 2.88 in United's favour.

Carrick's fortnight

The comeback does not end the debate. Friday marked the 40th anniversary of Sir Alex Ferguson's appointment, which followed a 1986 start so bad it cost Ron Atkinson his job. Goal noted this weekend that United had dropped into the bottom three after nine or more games for the first time since that November. They are still there, level on eight points with 19th-placed Sunderland, a point above Crystal Palace and one behind Forest and Coventry, per Sky Sports' table.

Carrick came into the game without any guarantee about his future. Asked whether he had been given assurances beyond the break, he told reporters: "No, no. Just carry on as absolute normal." Sports Illustrated reported him adding: "Whatever is going to happen is going to happen."

The Independent's Miguel Delaney reported on Friday that the hierarchy had been marked by indecision, with "little idea" over a replacement. He also pointed out that Villa had won once at Old Trafford in 15 years and that Emery had never won there. That record survives, just. Villa end the weekend 10th on 13 points.

United's next league match could hardly be less forgiving: Liverpool at Anfield on Sunday 22 November, kick-off 4.30pm UK time, per Liverpool FC. Whether Carrick takes charge there is down to Omar Berrada and Jason Wilcox, who already discussed his position after the defeat at Bournemouth, according to Birmingham Live. A point snatched this late buys some goodwill. It does not buy a fortnight of silence.

Key facts

  • Result: Manchester United 4-4 Aston Villa, Old Trafford, Sunday 8 November 2026.
  • Villa goals: Alysson 1', Nicolas Jackson 4', John McGinn 48' (pen), Leon Goretzka 53'.
  • United goals: Bruno Fernandes 16' (pen), Youri Tielemans 44', Joshua Zirkzee 90+2', Patrick Dorgu 90+6' (BBC Sport).
  • Dorgu's equaliser stood after a VAR check.
  • Shots: United 26, Villa 12; on target 9 to 6; xG 3.55 to 2.88 (BBC Sport).
  • Attendance: 74,149.
  • United: 18th on 8 points; Sunderland 19th on 8, Palace 20th on 7.
  • Villa: 10th on 13 points.
  • United's only league win this season: 5-2 against Ipswich on 30 August (Goal).
  • Next for United: Liverpool away, Sunday 22 November.

Sources

No comments yet