A decade-old wound reopened by the City verdict
Louis van Gaal has linked Manchester City's financial rule breaches to the end of his Manchester United tenure. In an email to The Athletic published on Thursday 15 October 2026, the Dutch coach said missing Champions League football in 2016 was "probably the deciding factor" in his dismissal, Goal.com and Football Today both reported.
United and City finished the 2015-16 Premier League season on 66 points. City took fourth place on goal difference in Manuel Pellegrini's final campaign. United finished fifth with only 49 league goals, Football Today noted. Van Gaal was sacked less than 24 hours after United beat Crystal Palace to win the FA Cup, Goal.com wrote, and Jose Mourinho replaced him.
"For me, at the time, that was probably the deciding factor in my dismissal from Manchester United," Van Gaal said of the Champions League miss, according to Football Today and Goal.com. He also referred to "the consequences and suffering that followed," Goal.com quoted from The Athletic exchange.
What the commission found, and what City say
An independent commission found City guilty of breaching 114 Premier League financial rules between 2009 and 2018, Goal.com and Football Today reported. The case covers sponsorship and accounting arrangements the league argued strengthened City's position. City have appealed, dispute the findings, and say they hold substantial evidence for their defence, Football Today wrote.
Van Gaal declined to prescribe a punishment. "Ultimately, that will have to be decided by the judge," he told The Athletic, per Football Today. Asked whether his United story might have ended differently in a fair competition, he answered: "That's for sure." He also said: "I cannot turn back history now," acknowledging that no ruling can reverse 2016.
Goal.com noted he has previously called missing the 2016 Champions League place one of the worst experiences of his professional life. His relationship with then-chief executive Ed Woodward collapsed after Van Gaal accused the executive of lining up Mourinho before the sacking, the same report said.
Why the quote lands this week
The Athletic interview arrives while City's appeal and possible sanctions remain open. Rival clubs and finance writers still debate commercial and sporting damage from the charged years. Van Gaal frames himself as an individual casualty of a Champions League place decided on goal difference against the club now judged to have broken the league's financial rules across that era.
He does not claim the verdict alone rewrites the 2015-16 table. He argues the missed European place was decisive for his exit after a trophy-winning season, and that the suffering that followed cannot be undone. The angle sits apart from City's midweek Champions League night against Paris Saint-Germain and from United's present Carrick crisis.
United sit deep in a different news cycle under Michael Carrick. Van Gaal's email is about 2016, goal difference, the FA Cup hangover, and whether fair competition would have kept him in the job. Football365 and other outlets had already floated legal chatter around damaged parties after the guilty findings; Thursday's primary hard news is Van Gaal speaking in his own words to The Athletic.
Key facts
- Van Gaal email to The Athletic reported 15 October 2026 (Goal.com, Football Today, Voetbalzone).
- United and City both on 66 points in 2015-16; City fourth on GD, United fifth with 49 PL goals.
- Van Gaal sacked under 24 hours after 2016 FA Cup win; Mourinho appointed (Goal.com).
- Quote: missing CL "probably the deciding factor" in his dismissal; "consequences and suffering" followed.
- Commission: City guilty of 114 PL financial breaches, 2009-2018; City appealing (Goal.com, Football Today).
- Van Gaal: "I cannot turn back history now"; punishment "decided by the judge."
- On whether outcome differs in fair competition: "That's for sure."
- Prior context: public debate on rival claims after the verdict (Football365 coverage of finance reaction).
No comments yet